I’m not sure why, but it is
extremely difficult for me to decide on my favorite moment in history, which
makes me feel sort of disappointed in myself because I like history. I can name a lot of important historical and
appreciate their importance but I don’t know if there is any particular moment
that is my favorite.
I think if I was asked this
question when I was in elementary school it would be a lot easier to answer
because now I have a better understanding of history and I see both sides of
the historical events they most commonly teach in schools. For example, Christopher Columbus is
introduced to students as a hero who discovered America, but he also enslaved
natives and introduced (unintentionally) disease that killed millions of
people. The American Revolution is
another example of a great moment in American history, but there was also so
much American and British blood shed and families destroyed. The Native Americans were also treated
horribly during that time. Even the
civil rights movement, which was successful in the end, endured years of
murders, police brutality, and the unfair treatment of innocent people for the
sole reason that they had a different color skin. I guess history is just like that, you can’t
have change without loss, but it’s hard to accept that and name any moment a
complete success.
If I were to identify moment in
history that was most significant to
my life I would choose that the attacks that occurred on September 11th,
2001. I don’t know if I can say there
was anything positive that occurred following the tragic events that occurred
that day but I do know that it impacted my life in a way I’ll never
forget. In 2001 I was in the third
grade, just old enough to kind of understand what was going on, and plenty
curious to want to fully understand. I
remember being outside in gym class that morning when a teacher came running
outside and discretely said something to our gym teacher who told us we had to
go inside. We didn’t know why but the
teacher that came outside was upset and so was our gym teacher after they
talked. We went back to our class and
they told us that planes crashed into the World Trade Center in New York City and
that it was a terrorist attack. My mom
came and picked me and my sister up from school and I didn’t really understand
why but I asked a million questions which she either didn’t have answers for
yet or didn’t want to tell me. I wasn’t
supposed to watch the news, but I did. I
wanted to know and I wanted to understand.
I asked my teacher questions everyday in class and I became obsessed with
America. I wanted to know everything about
the presidents and the government. I
just wanted to understand everything. I
read books about the presidents and about Washington DC. I asked so many questions and people never
knew whether or not they were supposed to answer them. I remember seeing American flags everywhere
after that day. They sold them at the
grocery store; people had them on their cars, houses, everywhere. I remember the red white and blue shirts that
said ‘these colors don’t run’, I remember the bumper stickers, I remember the
photo of the flag that was torn but still flying at ground zero, I remember
that all of the sudden everyone was American and proud of it. I think that what happened on September 11th,
2001 was the most significant moment in history for me because I was there and
I was old enough to kind of understand it or at least want to understand it. I think that was one of the first times that
I realized bad things could really happen in America. I think that’s when I understood what it
meant to be American.
Amanda,
ReplyDeleteThis is a great post! It's true that most of the greatest moments in American history have negative sides to them as well.
I actually wrote about 9/11 in my post too. I was in second grade, and, like you, it was one of the first moments in history that I explicitly remembered. In my post, I talked about how the greatest moment in history was when the three New York firemen raised the American flag near the remains of the World Trade Center. It was a symbol to the American people as well as other nations that America is strong and will get through the horrific event, and fight terrorism head on. While the attacks caused devastation, sadness, and anger, they didn't knock us down. The American people came together to fight for one thing they all loved: their home, the United States of America.
Wonderful job!